Tuesday, November 11, 2008

The Business of Bishops

~an excerpt from Fr. Richard John Neuhaus' article in First Things, Obama and the Bishops. One of the things I have heard from frustrated people since the election has been about the bishops and the ineffectual and oftentimes weak-kneed response concerning the evils of abortion. Some point to the wordy and nuanced Faithful Citizenship which they say opened the door to friends and family finding enough wiggle room to justify voting for a pro-abort candidate. Not all bishops were timorous, and in fact, for the first time since I've been able to vote, the past election season saw the amazing group of bishops who were strong in their statements (and equally amazing, though not surprising in retrospect, was the vitriol and dissent that their forceful teaching caused). Fr. Neuhaus offers the following insights:
It is the business of bishops to help equip the faithful to let the splendor of moral truth shine through their life and witness as lights in the world. If, on occasion, that coincides with political success, it is to be viewed as an unexpected, albeit welcome, bonus. It is a grievous degradation of their pastoral office, as well as a political delusion, for bishops to see themselves as managers of the Catholic voting bloc.

...That unintended invitation to distort, eagerly seized upon by those with a mind to do so, was especially evident in the statement’s treatment of a “proportionate” reason to support pro-abortion candidates. The bishops must do better next time. To be sure, any statement must be carefully reasoned, as Catholic moral theology is carefully reasoned. Yet an episcopal statement is not an invitation to an academic seminar but, above all, a call to faithfulness. The task is to offer a firm, unambiguous, and, as much as possible, a persuasive case on the basis of revelation and clear reason.

The events of these months have once again exposed deeper problems in the leadership of the bishops, although certainly not of the bishops alone. To cite an obvious instance, only 25 to 35 percent (depending on whose data you believe) of the 68 million Catholics in this country regularly attend Mass. That means that, except for a few bishops who have larger media access, bishops are being heard by only a minority of their people. Moreover, many parish pastors and priests are embarrassingly eager to avoid controversy, and others are openly disdainful of the Church’s teaching and/or its implications for public justice. Some bishops are tremulously intimidated by their presbyterates. Such bishops and priests need to read again, and with soul-searching prayer, Paul’s counsel to Timothy.

There are deeper problems. In the last four decades, following the pattern of American Protestantism, many, perhaps most, Catholics view the Church in terms of consumption rather than obligation. The Church is there to supply their spiritual needs as they define those needs, not to tell them what to believe or do.[my emphasis] This runs very deep both sociologically and psychologically. It is part of the “success” of American Catholics in becoming just like everybody else. Bishops and all of us need to catch the vision of John Paul II that the Church imposes nothing, she only proposes. But what she proposes she believes is the truth, and because human beings are hard-wired for the truth, the truth imposes. And truth obliges.

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

If only the episcopate stood up, this much, to pro-aborts from the moment Roe vs Wade misinterpreted the Constitution, in 1973; abortion might just be illegal by now.

It seems that the backbone that the bishops found this election cycle was too little to late,
God is in charge.
We know how the story ends: the abolition of abortion, hopefully soon.
We must always take joy in Christs Death and Ressurection, without ever giving up the fight.
Deo Gratias!